Monday, 16 November 2026

The Sycophant-Authoritarian Dynamic

Sycophants think they can elevate themselves in terms of wealth and power by shamelessly backing authoritarian leaders who will reward them. In turn, those leaders welcome their support, not just for the ego massage, but for three valuable ingredients for securing widespread domination.


First, sycophants, in possession of money and status, provide a sense of legitimacy through their vocal endorsement. Someone seeking oppressive power could frighten a lot of people away. But if established figures are willing to say that person is one they would wholeheartedly back, others may come to adopt a more favourable view too.


Secondly, authoritarian figures are by their own nature anti-cooperative. They put their own desires and ambitions above the interests of everyone else. Sycophants, however, can help open doors for them – contact lists, networking events, exclusive meetings, all leading to more opportunities for lies to be sold as unmissable offers, raw deals packaged as special bargains.


Thirdly, sycophants say it with money. They show they are at one with their chosen aspiring autocrat by lavishing them with gifts, donations, and other financial transfers. And money boosts influence through lobbying, false advertising, crowd manipulation, social media deception, and countless other means of undermining opponents.


But why don’t sycophants learn from history? The more power authoritarians gain from their support, the more likely they can be so powerful they can do whatever they want – even at the expense of the sycophants. Unfortunately, the very impulse that fuels sycophantic behaviour is what tends to override a person’s moral sensibility.


Most people can sense the danger posed by anyone who consistently exhibits self-absorption, ruthlessness, superficial charms, callous disregard for others, and uninhibited mendacity. And they keep a good distance away from them. But some are so drawn to the selfish gains they believe they can make from siding unreservedly with such a manipulator that they switch off their most basic sense of judgement. Not only do the sufferings of others at the hands of authoritarian leaders mean nothing to them, they become incapable of seeing that their own wellbeing is endangered by the inexorable rise of the power-grabber.


Time and time again, sycophants throw in their lot with wannabe authoritarians. From ambitious usurpers of the imperial Roman throne, through the rise of fascist dictators, to contemporary illiberal xenophobic leaders, sycophants sing the praises of vile characters because they think they would be well looked after when those characters obtain overwhelming power. At some stage, it may dawn on them that the monster they helped to unleash is out of control, but often by then they are too scared to show any sign of dissent. 


Ironically, their reluctance to point out the errors of authoritarian leaders, and their mindless echoing of destructive ideas, inevitably means that those leaders increasingly seal themselves off in a bubble of delusions. Their imaginary achievements are loudly applauded. Their mistakes are left in place. Only those who endorse even the most unpalatable decisions are allowed to speak. Then together they reap the calamitous ending they’ve sown.

Sunday, 1 November 2026

Why Epistemology Matters

Epistemology, a classic topic in philosophy, often conjures up surreal discussions about how one is to know if one is not permanently in a dream, or if one is nothing more than the thoughts of a disembodied brain kept alive in some laboratory. But leaving aside these teasing puzzles, the core issue is about how one can determine if what one believes to be true, is in fact true.


It turns out that while speculating idly by oneself may be fun, if one is to get through life, one has to learn from experience what is dependable and what is dubious. We cannot afford to suspend all beliefs or hold arbitrary assumptions when we might end up being seriously harmed. Our experiences are what we have to work with to help us interpret what is happening now and anticipate what we may come across in the future.


Philosophers such as Francis Bacon, David Hume, J. S. Mill, John Dewey, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Karl Popper, have in their different ways explained why we need to refer to our experiences – gathering evidence, conducting experiments, exchanging observations, testing predictions – to inform our views on what we may provisionally claim to know, subject to future reviews and revisions. In practice, this involves openness in communications, recognition of acquired expertise, impartial adjudication of rival claims, cooperation in research and examination, and deliberative assessment that is free from coercion, bribery and deception.


It is therefore essential for a broadly communitarian – inclusively empirical, openly cooperative – form of epistemology to prevail in society if we are to be able to have any kind of common understanding and shared evaluative processes relating to what are acceptable claims and what should be rejected. This has a number of key implications.


First, education should not be a system of dogmatic transmission of ‘truths’, but ought to nurture cooperative enquiry, evidence-based scrutiny, and a critical understanding of how truth-claims should in general be assessed and where appropriate, revised. Everyone should learn about the empirical basis of knowledge so that all are vigilant in guarding against claims which do not stand up to objective scrutiny, and insistent on demanding verifiable validation beyond pseudo-justifications such as ‘I just know’, ‘I can tell my children whatever I want’, ‘I heard it from God’, or ‘this has always been the position of my people’.


Secondly, just as we do not allow people to inflict harm on others by direct physical acts, we must not permit harm to be done by epistemological manipulations. Lies, malicious rumours, fallacious theories, distorted reports, biased data presentations, can all lead to people hurting themselves as well as others. Societies are already damaged through countless citizens being misled into believing that something dangerous is harmless, or that something innocuous poses the most terrible threat. The relativist delusion that ‘everyone is entitled to their own view’ has to be put aside, especially when accurate statements are dismissed by charlatans as ‘fake news’, while falsehoods are propagated as (in some cases literally) gospel.


Thirdly, pedagogical and regulatory actions need to be guided by communitarian evaluative capability. In our research institutions; professional standards bodies; authorised investigators; recognised judges and adjudicators, we need training in conducting objective examination, cultivation of open-mindedness and impartiality, organisational support for continuous development, and safeguards against threats and corruption. Collectively, they enable us to differentiate, with confidence and integrity, what claims we can rely on, what need further examination, and what should be rejected.


Ignorance spreads when people buy into the nonsense of ‘nobody really knows anything’. Con merchants thrive when people embrace falsehoods more readily than truths. We need sound epistemological thinking to reinforce the educative, communicative, and investigative practices we have, to ensure that our experiences systematically inform the way claims and assertions are evaluated. 

--


For more on epistemology and practical policies, explore the essays collected in What Should Citizens Believe.